Energy is the largest cost in any pig diet, and the way you measure it changes which ingredients look cheap. Digestible energy (DE) and metabolizable energy (ME) have long been the standard, but net energy (NE) is now widely used because it reflects what the pig actually uses for maintenance and growth. This article explains the differences between the three systems, why NE ranks ingredients differently, how to use NE values in formulation, and where the system still has limits, so you can judge whether your nutritionist's choice of energy system is costing you money.
The energy cascade in the pig
Gross energy is the heat released when a feed is burned. Part of it is lost in feces, leaving digestible energy. Part of the digestible energy is lost in urine and as combustible gases, leaving metabolizable energy. Finally, the pig loses heat during digestion, absorption and nutrient metabolism, called the heat increment. What remains is net energy, available for maintenance and for deposition of protein and fat. Each step down the cascade removes energy, and ingredients lose different amounts at each step. That is the entire reason the three systems disagree.
DE and ME: simple and widely used
DE is easy to measure and was the basis of older feed tables. ME corrects for urinary losses, which are large when excess protein is fed because nitrogen is excreted as urea. Both systems treat a calorie of digestible fat, starch, fiber or protein as roughly equal in value, which is not how the pig experiences them. In practice, ME values are about 95 to 97 percent of DE for typical corn and soybean meal diets. The systems work acceptably when diets are similar, but they mislead when you compare very different ingredients.
Why NE changes the ranking
The heat increment differs strongly between nutrients. Fat and starch generate little extra heat, so most of their ME becomes net energy. Protein and fiber generate more heat, so a smaller share of their ME is usable. Under an NE system, ingredients high in fat or starch are worth more per ME calorie, while high-fiber and high-protein ingredients are worth less.
| Ingredient type | DE or ME view | NE view |
|---|---|---|
| Added fat or oil | Good | Even better |
| Corn, wheat, other starches | Good | Good |
| Wheat middlings, bran, hulls | Fair | Lower |
| Soybean meal, canola meal | Fair | Lower |
| Distillers grains | Fair to good | Noticeably lower |
Practical formulation implications
If you formulate to a fixed ME specification, you may overvalue by-products such as middlings, distillers grains or rice bran, so the least-cost solution can underdeliver on net energy. The pigs will eat to satisfy energy needs, so lower real energy density raises feed intake and worsens feed conversion. Switching to NE usually shifts the formulation toward more corn and added fat, and away from fibrous co-products. Typical NE specifications for finishing diets fall around 2,400 to 2,550 kcal per kilogram, and your nutritionist should set the target for your genetics.
Fiber, fat and the limits of the system
NE values for fibrous ingredients are not constants. Growing pigs digest fiber less well than sows, so a distillers value measured in one class does not transfer to another. Dietary fat has a higher energy value in young pigs than starch in some circumstances, and fat quality, free fatty acid level and oxidation all affect the figure. Housing and temperature also matter, because a pig below its thermoneutral zone burns net energy as heat. Always combine NE tables with your own feed analysis and performance data, especially when using a single supplier's book values. See high-fiber diets for finishing pigs for how fiber behaves in practice.
Using NE in least-cost formulation
Practical steps for moving to an NE-based system:
- Choose a trusted ingredient matrix, ideally one published by a recognized swine nutrition source, and use it consistently.
- Set the NE specification and keep the lysine-to-NE ratio constant as diets change.
- Check that the formulated diet still meets minimum fiber and maximum bulk limits, since NE does not cap physical bulk.
- Compare cost per unit of NE, not cost per pound of feed, when buying fat, oil or by-products.
- Review the results against feed conversion and gain, and adjust the matrix if the barn does not match predictions.
Where the energy system matters most
The choice has the biggest effect in diets with large inclusions of co-products, in late finishing where high-fiber diets are common, and in lactation diets where intake is limited. It also matters when comparing corn-soybean diets with wheat-based or barley-based diets from other regions. For simple corn-soy rations the three systems give similar answers, and the effort of a switch brings little benefit. The corn and soybean meal ration guide explains the baseline diet, and DDGS inclusion limits shows why by-products get special scrutiny.
Checking real-world performance
An energy system is only a model. Verify it by tracking average daily feed intake, gain and feed conversion across diet changes. If pigs eat more than expected on a diet formulated to the same NE, the actual energy value is lower than the table suggests. Calibrate with a few pens before changing the whole barn, and record batch-to-batch variation of fat sources and co-products. The feed conversion ratio article describes how to calculate your numbers consistently.
FAQ
Is net energy always better than metabolizable energy?
It predicts growth more accurately when diets contain very different ingredients, but for simple corn and soybean meal diets the difference is small and either system works.
Why does soybean meal have less net energy than its ME value suggests?
Protein generates a larger heat increment during metabolism, so a smaller fraction of its metabolizable energy ends up available for growth.
Do I need to change my feed if my nutritionist moves to NE?
Not necessarily, but expect more corn and added fat and less fibrous co-product, which can change feed cost and feed intake.