SwineFarming.org

Home › Articles › Swine Housing Deep Dives › Slurry Management: Underfloor vs. Pull-Plug Systems

Swine Housing Deep Dives

Slurry Management: Underfloor vs. Pull-Plug Systems

Slurry is the mix of manure, urine, spilled water and bedding that collects in the pits beneath slatted floors. How you store and remove it affects air quality, pig health, odor, safety and the value of the nutrients you recover. This article compares underfloor deep pits and pull-plug systems, explains how storage capacity and agitation work, and covers the hazards that come with handling slurry. It is aimed at producers planning a barn, evaluating an existing system or trying to reduce gas problems and pumping costs.

What slurry is and why management matters

Slurry typically contains a few percent solids, with the rest water. It contains nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and organic matter that make it a valuable fertilizer, but it also releases ammonia, hydrogen sulfide, methane and carbon dioxide as it decomposes. In a closed barn those gases affect pigs and workers, linked to Air Quality Monitoring: Ammonia and Dust Thresholds and Hydrogen Sulfide in Slurry: Health Risks and Monitoring.

Good management keeps slurry from accumulating to the slats, limits agitation inside occupied barns, and provides a plan to land-apply it according to crop needs and local rules.

Underfloor deep pits

Deep pits sit beneath the slatted floor and store manure for months, often a year, before being pumped out. They are simple and robust, with fewer moving parts and less frequent handling. The pit may be several feet deep and sized to hold the manure of the pigs over the planned storage period.

The downsides are that large volumes of decomposing manure sit under the pigs, which can produce harmful gases and odor, and pumping out can release a surge of gas. Pit ventilation and careful agitation planning are critical. See Manure Storage Lagoons: Liners and Monitoring for the alternative of outside storage.

Pull-plug and flush systems

In a pull-plug system, shallow pits are drained at regular intervals by pulling a plug, often every several weeks, sending manure to an outside storage or lagoon. Because the manure leaves the building frequently, the air under the slats is generally fresher and the gases are lower than in deep pits.

Related are flush systems, which use recycled water to rinse the channel. These need more water and a lagoon or treatment system. Pull-plug barns need reliable piping, enough slope for drainage and an outside storage with adequate capacity. Pipe blockages from solids or bedding can be a recurring problem.

Comparing the systems

FactorDeep pitPull-plug
Gas in barnHigher potentialLower
Handling frequencyLowHigher
Outside storageOptionalRequired
ComplexitySimpleMore piping
Odor from barnOften higher at pump-outLower in barn

Neither system is universally better. Pit systems may suit operations with direct application equipment, while pull-plug suits those that already have outside storage.

Capacity and storage planning

Plan for the number of pigs, daily manure production and the time between application windows, which depends on weather, crop schedule and regulation. Extension publications and local engineers provide manure production figures by pig weight, so use those rather than guesses. Add freeboard for rainfall if storage is outdoors.

Know your local rules. Many states have permitting, setback and nutrient management requirements, and these change, so verify with your state agency. See Pig Farming Laws and Zoning: What to Check Before You Buy Pigs for an overview of the regulatory landscape.

Agitation and pump-out safety

Agitating slurry stirs up trapped gases, and hydrogen sulfide can reach lethal concentrations within seconds to minutes. Safe practice includes:

  1. Removing pigs from the building or ensuring maximum ventilation during pump-out when possible.
  2. Running ventilation at full capacity and opening curtains or doors.
  3. Keeping people out of the barn during agitation.
  4. Using portable gas monitors and never entering pits or confined spaces without proper training and equipment.
  5. Starting agitation at the pit end farthest from the pigs and monitoring animals constantly.

Many livestock deaths and worker fatalities have been linked to manure gas, and the danger is real even for experienced crews.

Reducing problems at the source

Reduce water wastage from leaking drinkers, which dilutes slurry and fills storage faster. See Drinker Flow Rates: Nipple vs. Bowl vs. Cup for setup. Manage feed to limit excess nutrients excreted. Keep slats clean and fix cracked pits to prevent leaks.

Additives are marketed to reduce odor or solids; evidence is mixed, so test on a small scale and consult your veterinarian or extension specialist before relying on them.

Land application and value

Sample slurry for nutrient content before application and calibrate equipment, since nutrient levels vary by system and dilution. Apply at agronomic rates, consider incorporation or injection to reduce loss and odor, and keep records. Nutrient value can offset fertilizer cost, and some programs trade or share manure nutrients, as in Manure Nutrient Trading Programs.

FAQ

How often should a deep pit be emptied?

Many are emptied once or twice a year based on storage capacity and crop schedules, but timing depends on your design, local rules and field conditions.

Why is pump-out dangerous?

Agitation releases trapped gases such as hydrogen sulfide, which can quickly reach harmful or fatal levels, so ventilation, monitoring and removing people and animals when possible are essential.

Do pull-plug systems eliminate odor?

No, but they usually reduce gases inside the barn. Odor can still come from outside storage and during land application.

Keep learning

Browse all 700 guides →