SwineFarming.org

Home › Articles › Pork as Food & Nutrition › Pork Shoulder vs. Butt: Cut Identification

Pork as Food & Nutrition

Pork Shoulder vs. Butt: Cut Identification

Few cuts cause more confusion at the meat counter than pork shoulder and pork butt. Despite the name, the butt is not from the rear of the pig. Both come from the front shoulder region, and both are ideal for pulled pork, carnitas and braising. This article explains how the shoulder is divided, what each part is called in American and international usage, how to identify the cuts, and how to choose and cook them, so you can buy the right piece and avoid wasted money or dry meat.

Where the shoulder sits

The pork shoulder is a primal that includes the entire front leg region above the hock. In US butchery it is typically separated into two sections. The upper part is the Boston butt (or Boston shoulder), and the lower part is the picnic shoulder (or picnic ham). The cut lines follow the shoulder blade and arm bone, and a full overview appears in Pork Cuts Guide: Primal Cuts, Retail Cuts, Cooking Methods and Yield.

Boston butt

The Boston butt is the upper, rectangular-ish portion, often 6 to 10 pounds when bone-in. It contains part of the blade bone and is well marbled with intramuscular fat. Its name reportedly comes from Colonial New England butchers who packed pork cuts into barrels, called butts.

Characteristics:

  • Rich marbling, relatively uniform shape.
  • Contains the shoulder blade, which pulls free when cooked.
  • Great for pulled pork, since collagen and fat keep it moist.
  • Often sold as "pork butt" or "Boston roast."

Picnic shoulder

The picnic is the lower portion, tapering toward the hock, and it includes the arm bone and often the skin. It is slightly leaner, with more connective tissue and a less uniform shape. It is sometimes sold skin-on, and it can be cured and smoked into a "picnic ham," which is not a true ham from the hind leg.

FeatureBoston buttPicnic shoulder
LocationUpper shoulderLower shoulder
ShapeBlockyTapered
MarblingHighModerate
BoneBlade boneArm bone
Typical usePulled pork, sausageBraising, curing, carnitas
SkinUsually offOften on

Identifying a cut at the counter

Labels differ across stores and countries. Sometimes a package simply says "pork shoulder," and the contents may be butt, picnic or a whole shoulder. Ask the butcher. If you see a rectangular roast with a flat bone and good marbling, it is probably butt. A tapered, skinned or skin-on piece with a round bone is probably picnic.

International terminology adds confusion. In the UK, "hand" and "spring" refer to portions of the shoulder, and "collar" is the neck end of the shoulder. In Latin American markets, "paleta" refers to the shoulder. For other countries, see Pork in Latin American Cooking.

Cooking temperatures and methods

Shoulder is a tough, collagen-rich muscle group. It is safe at 145F with a three-minute rest, but is tough at that temperature, as covered in Cooking Temperatures for Pork: USDA Guidelines. For tender shredded meat, cook to about 195F to 205F.

Methods include:

  1. Smoke or barbecue: 225F to 275F for many hours, see Smoking Pork: Temperature and Time Protocols and Barbecue Pork: Regional American Styles.
  2. Oven braise: 300F in a covered pot for 3 to 5 hours.
  3. Slow cooker: low for 8 to 10 hours, see Slow Cooker Pork: Food Safety and Technique.
  4. Pressure cook: Cut into chunks, cook about an hour.
  5. Sous vide: long cook at 165F to 175F, see Sous Vide Pork: Safety and Quality.

Cooking times depend on size, shape and equipment, so use a probe. Resting for at least 30 minutes to an hour improves moisture.

Seasoning and trimming

Leave a layer of fat, about a quarter-inch, since it bastes the meat. Cut off any thick, hard lumps. Rub salt overnight for a dry brine, since salt penetrates slowly into big roasts and seasons deeply. Rubs with paprika, garlic and pepper form bark during smoking.

Fat cap, skin and bone

The fat cap faces up or down depending on your heat source. In a smoker with indirect heat, it generally does not matter. Bone-in roasts cook a bit more evenly and provide a doneness test: when the blade bone pulls out clean, the meat is ready. Boneless roasts are easier to carve but dry out faster.

Other uses

Butt is the standard meat for fresh sausage, since the fat-to-lean ratio is ideal. See Sausage Manufacturing: Pork Blends and Texture and Ground Pork: Fat Content and Shelf Life. Shoulder is also used in cured products such as coppa, which comes from the neck end, and in carnitas, which are simmered in lard, covered in Lard: Rendering and Culinary Uses.

Quality and price

Shoulder is among the most affordable and forgiving cuts. Pork with good intramuscular fat, from breeds like Duroc, tends to be juicier, and pale, watery meat can turn out dry. Watch for packages with excess liquid, and choose firm, pink meat.

FAQ

Is pork butt the same as pork shoulder?

Pork butt, or Boston butt, is the upper part of the shoulder. Pork shoulder can mean the whole shoulder, the butt or the picnic, so check the label.

Which cut is best for pulled pork?

Boston butt is the preferred choice because of its marbling and uniform shape. Picnic shoulder also works, though it is slightly leaner and needs more trimming.

Why does pork shoulder need to reach 200F when 145F is safe?

Safety is reached at 145F, but tenderness comes from collagen turning into gelatin at higher temperatures. At 145F the meat is still tough and does not shred.

Keep learning

Browse all 700 guides →